Brain injuries present a unique challenge in personal injury claims. Despite their devastating impact, insurance companies routinely undervalue these injuries to minimize payouts. Understanding how insurers undervalue these claims—and how to effectively counter their tactics—can make the difference between inadequate compensation and recovery that truly addresses the victim’s needs.
When seeking compensation for a brain injury, hiring an experienced attorney should be a top priority. You may not have the time or energy your case requires, and your personal injury lawyer’s experience with brain injury cases is another important reason to rely on them.
Schedule A Free Case Consultation
The Hidden But Devastating Nature of Brain Injuries
Unlike many physical injuries, traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) often lack obvious external signs, making them easier for insurers to discount or deny. Yet, while symptoms of a brain injury are not as visible as a bruise or scar, they can be far more debilitating.
This “invisible” quality creates significant challenges for victims seeking fair compensation. When dealing with brain injury claims, insurance companies frequently exploit the fact that:
- Many mild to moderate TBIs don’t appear on standard CT scans or MRIs
- Symptoms may develop gradually rather than immediately after trauma
- The connection between the accident and cognitive symptoms can be difficult to document
- Everyday functioning may appear normal during brief interactions despite significant deficits
- Victims may look perfectly healthy despite suffering from serious cognitive impairments
This hidden-symptom factor gives insurance adjusters ample opportunity to question whether an injury exists at all or to suggest it’s less severe than you claim. Without physical evidence and expert testimony, brain injury victims face an uphill battle from the start.
Common Tactics Insurers Use to Devalue Brain Injury Claims
Insurance companies employ several specific strategies designed to minimize brain injury compensation. Recognizing these tactics is the first step toward effectively countering them. A lawyer will quickly identify and stop these bad-faith strategies, which may include:
Questioning Diagnosis and Causation
Insurers routinely challenge the very existence or cause of brain injuries by:
- Highlighting the lack of positive findings on standard imaging studies
- Attributing cognitive symptoms to psychological factors like stress or anxiety
- Suggesting symptoms are exaggerated or fabricated for financial gain
- Arguing that symptoms existed before the accident or resulted from unrelated causes
- Pointing to gaps in medical treatment as evidence that the injury isn’t serious
This strategy aims to create doubt about whether a compensable injury actually occurred. By questioning the fundamental basis of the claim, insurers position themselves to justify minimal offers or outright denials.
Minimizing the Long-Term Impact on the Patient
Brain injuries are a multi-billion-dollar problem. The severe cost of these injuries is well known. Yet, when they can’t deny the injury outright, insurers work to downplay its lasting effects by:
- Rushing settlement offers before the full extent of cognitive impairment becomes clear
- Suggesting that cognitive symptoms will improve quickly with minimal treatment
- Ignoring the impact of executive function deficits on career potential and earning capacity
- Downplaying how memory, concentration, and processing speed problems affect daily life
- Focusing solely on physical recovery while disregarding cognitive and emotional aspects
Insurers justify substantially lower settlement offers by framing brain injuries as temporary inconveniences rather than life-altering conditions. This approach fails to account for the complex, often permanent nature of brain trauma.
Engaging in Intrusive Surveillance (Often Including Social Media Monitoring)
Insurers look for every available edge in high-value claims. These companies increasingly use surveillance tactics to undermine brain injury claims by:
- Hiring investigators to record victims going about the claimant’s daily activities
- Mining social media posts for evidence of activities that seem inconsistent with claimed limitations
- Taking brief moments of normal functioning out of context to suggest the victim is exaggerating
- Using selected footage that doesn’t capture cognitive struggles or fatigue following activities
- Recording interactions without capturing the preparation, rest, or assistance that made them possible
These surveillance tactics create a misleading picture, as they fail to capture the cognitive effort, exhaustion, and assistance that may be required for brain injury survivors to participate in occasional activities.
Misrepresenting Medical Evidence
The complex medical evidence in brain injury cases provides another opportunity for undervaluation, as insurance companies are known for:
- Cherry-picking isolated findings from lengthy medical records while ignoring the overall clinical picture
- Focusing on negative diagnostic tests rather than positive clinical evaluations
- Highlighting minor inconsistencies in medical records to suggest unreliability
- Obtaining selective insurance medical examinations (IMEs) from doctors known for conservative opinions
- Challenging the credentials or methodologies of neuropsychologists and other brain injury specialists
By exploiting the complex and sometimes contradictory nature of medical documentation, insurers create uncertainty about diagnosis and prognosis—uncertainty they use to justify reduced valuations.
Effective Strategies Your Lawyer Will Use to Fight Back Against Bad Faith
While insurance companies have developed sophisticated methods for undervaluing brain injury claims, victims and their attorneys can employ equally effective countermeasures to ensure fair compensation. Your personal injury attorney may fight back through:
Comprehensive Medical Documentation
Building a strong foundation of medical evidence is essential:
- Seek evaluation from specialists in neurology, neuropsychology, and physical medicine
- Undergo comprehensive neuropsychological testing that quantifies cognitive deficits
- Consider advanced imaging such as DTI (diffusion tensor imaging) or functional MRIs that may detect subtle abnormalities
- Maintain detailed symptom journals documenting cognitive issues, fatigue, and emotional changes
- Obtain medical opinions that specifically address causation and long-term prognosis
This thorough documentation makes it harder for insurers to dismiss or minimize the injury. When multiple specialists using various diagnostic approaches reach similar conclusions, the reality of the injury becomes more difficult to dispute.
Citing Reliable Witnesses
One of the most powerful ways to demonstrate the impact of a brain injury is through testimony from people who knew the victim before and after the injury:
- Family members who can detail personality changes and daily functioning difficulties
- Coworkers who have observed workplace performance changes
- Friends who have noticed social interaction differences
- Teachers or educational professionals who can document academic changes
- Employers who can attest to pre-injury capabilities versus post-injury limitations
These witnesses provide compelling evidence of real-world functional changes that insurance adjusters cannot easily dismiss. Their observations help translate medical jargon into tangible, relatable impacts that clearly demonstrate how the injury has changed the victim’s life.
Commissioning a Detailed Life Care Plan
A comprehensive life care plan developed by qualified experts counters insurance company undervaluation by specifically outlining future needs:
- Projections for ongoing medical treatment, therapy, and medication requirements
- Costs for cognitive rehabilitation and occupational therapy
- Expenses for adaptive technology and home modifications
- Estimates for necessary personal assistance or caregiving
- Calculations for reduced earning capacity and vocational rehabilitation needs
This detailed planning provides concrete figures that insurance adjusters must address, making it harder for them to offer arbitrary, inadequate settlement amounts that fail to account for long-term needs.
Paying for an Economic Impact Analysis
Brain injuries often have catastrophic financial consequences that extend far beyond immediate medical bills:
- Partner with vocational rehabilitation specialists to document work limitations
- Engage economic experts to calculate lifetime earnings losses
- Document the cost of replacing household services that the victim can no longer perform
- Quantify educational opportunities lost due to cognitive impairments
- Calculate the financial impact of reduced career advancement potential
By providing detailed economic analysis, you force insurers to confront the true financial impact of the injury rather than focusing solely on medical expenses already incurred.
Using Cutting-Edge Technology
Modern technology offers powerful tools for demonstrating the reality of brain injuries:
- Create day-in-the-life videos showing struggles with everyday tasks
- Use medical illustrations and animations to explain the mechanism of injury
- Present before-and-after cognitive test results in clear graphical formats
- Utilize digital calendars and assistive device records to document ongoing limitations
- Compile video testimonials from treatment providers explaining the injury’s impact
These visual and technological presentations make abstract medical concepts concrete and understandable, helping claims adjusters, mediators, or jurors grasp the true nature of the injury.
Schedule A Free Case Consultation
Negotiation and Settlement Strategies Your Attorney May Use to Secure Fair Compensation for Your TBI
Effective negotiation requires both preparation and tactical skills to counter insurance company tactics.
Exercising Patience in the Negotiation Process
Brain injury cases require strategic patience, so expect your attorney to:
- Resist early settlement offers before the full extent of the injury is known
- Allow time for symptoms to stabilize and for appropriate treatment to demonstrate its effect
- Document failed treatment approaches to demonstrate the permanence of certain deficits
- Build a comprehensive record of how the injury affects all aspects of life over time
- Wait until medical experts can provide reliable long-term prognoses
This patience allows the full impact of the injury to emerge, making it harder for insurers to argue for quick, minimal settlements based on incomplete information.
Being Ready to Litigate
Sometimes, the most effective negotiation strategy is demonstrating willingness to take the case to court. If you need to take legal action, your brain injury attorney will:
- File a lawsuit before considering serious settlement discussions
- Complete the discovery process, exposing the weaknesses in the insurer’s position
- Depose the insurer’s medical experts to highlight biases or incomplete evaluations
- Prepare compelling demonstrative exhibits for trial
- Engage qualified expert witnesses who can effectively communicate with jurors
Insurance companies often increase offers substantially when they recognize that the victim’s legal team is fully prepared to present a compelling case at trial.
Addressing Challenges Head-On
Effective negotiation requires directly confronting common adjuster arguments. Your lawyer will stand up for you and your claim, and they may:
- Counter claims of pre-existing conditions with before-and-after evidence of functioning
- Address surveillance evidence by explaining the difference between occasional activities and sustained functioning
- Respond to the minimization of symptoms by providing detailed documentation from multiple sources
- Challenge insurance medical examinations with more thorough evaluations of treating physicians
- Counter-low settlement offers with specific references to comparable case verdicts and settlements
By anticipating and directly addressing these arguments with specific evidence, you demonstrate that undervaluation tactics won’t succeed.
Seeking compensation is a personal injury lawyer’s job. Even in complex cases like yours, a lawyer forges ahead and demands justice. Rely on their legal experience, knowledge of the law, and tenacity to deliver results.
Possible Damages in Your Brain Injury Case
Your lawyer will become extremely familiar with your damages, as those will be the centerpiece of your case. Some damages you might suffer because of a brain injury are:
- Medical expenses already incurred, possibly including emergency treatment, hospitalization, surgeries, diagnostic tests, and acute rehabilitation
- Future medical expenses for ongoing treatment
- Rehabilitation costs covering physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, cognitive rehabilitation, and psychological treatment
- Specialized equipment expenses such as mobility devices, communication aids, memory assistance technology, and home modifications
- Lost income from missed work during the initial recovery and treatment periods
- Diminished earning capacity when the brain injury affects the victim’s ability to perform their previous job or advance in their career
- Pain and suffering compensation for the physical discomfort associated with the injury and treatment
- Mental anguish damages addressing depression, anxiety, PTSD, and other psychological impacts common after brain trauma
- Loss of enjoyment of life when the victim can no longer participate in previously valued activities, hobbies, or recreation
- Cognitive deficits, including memory problems, attention difficulties, processing speed reductions, and executive function impairments
- Personality and behavioral changes that can fundamentally alter relationships with family members and friends
- Permanent disability compensation when the brain injury results in lasting impairments
- Lifetime care costs for severe cases requiring around-the-clock assistance or
- Punitive damages in cases where the defendant’s conduct was particularly reckless or intentional
Your personal injury lawyer will also account for wrongful death damages if the brain injury ultimately results in the victim’s death, including funeral expenses and loss of financial support.
Treatment for your brain injury alone may be far more than you can afford. As you can see, the cost of your injury will likely range far beyond treatment costs. Let an attorney fight for all the compensation your damages entitle you to.
When to Seek Legal Help After Suffering a Brain Injury (Right Away)
Brain injury survivors almost always benefit from having competent legal counsel. Consider seeking an attorney who:
- Has specific experience with traumatic brain injury cases
- Maintains relationships with qualified medical experts in neurology and neuropsychology
- Understands the complex interplay between medical evidence and legal strategy
- Has successfully tried brain injury cases to verdict when necessary
- Possesses the financial resources to fully develop complex medical evidence
Attorneys bring legal experience and knowledge about the medical aspects of brain injuries. They know how to document and present these complex cases effectively. Their experience with insurance company tactics allows them to effectively anticipate and counter undervaluation strategies.
Find Your Medical Malpractice Attorney Today
Complete free consultations today to find the best medical malpractice attorney to lead your case.