With more people ordering meals through delivery apps like DoorDash and Grubhub, accidents involving delivery drivers have become more common. If one of these drivers hit you as you were driving, walking, or cycling, you're likely wondering who is responsible for a DoorDash or Grubhub driver’s negligence?
These cases often involve more than just the driver. The company, other drivers, restaurants, and even local governments might all play a role.
Delivery services have changed the way we eat, but they’ve also added new risks to the road. When an accident happens, victims may face medical bills, lost time from work, and other hardships. Sorting out who should pay those costs isn’t always straightforward.
If a food delivery driver caused a crash that hurt you or a loved one, you might be entitled to compensation for medical treatment, time off work, vehicle repairs, and more. You may even be eligible for pain and suffering or wrongful death benefits if the worst has happened.
Talking to a rideshare accident attorney near you can help clarify your options. Most offer free consultations and work on contingency, so you don’t pay unless you recover damages.
Schedule A Free Case Consultation
Understanding Delivery Driver Classification
Food delivery platforms treat their drivers as independent contractors, not employees. This choice protects companies from some legal responsibility. But that doesn’t mean you’re out of luck if a delivery driver causes a crash.
Independent Contractors vs. Employees
The difference between an employee and an independent contractor matters a lot in these cases. Employees work directly under a company’s control. Independent contractors are self-employed and use the app as a middleman to find work. Because of this, companies like DoorDash and Grubhub often claim they aren't legally responsible for what their drivers do.
How Classification Affects Liability
Independent contractor status makes it harder to hold the delivery company accountable. It also affects which insurance policy will cover your damages. Employees typically fall under an employer’s liability insurance. Contractors don’t always get that protection.
Recent Legal Challenges and Changes
Some courts and lawmakers have started pushing back. California, for example, passed laws that make it harder for companies to classify workers as independent contractors. Legal battles continue across the country, which means the rules may change depending on where your accident happened.
Impact on Victims
These classifications matter because they decide who pays. If the driver is considered a contractor and the company isn’t liable, then recovering compensation can take longer and involve more legal steps.
Is DoorDash or Grubhub Liable for Their Drivers' Actions?
Delivery platforms often argue they aren't responsible for driver behavior. But that argument doesn’t always hold up. Certain actions or company policies might make them share the blame.
Courts sometimes find that the company bears responsibility, depending on the facts of the case.
Vicarious Liability Principles
In some situations, courts apply vicarious liability. This is a legal concept that holds a company responsible for the actions of someone working on its behalf. If the platform directs how a driver completes their job, that control can tip the scales toward liability.
For example, if the app tells the driver which route to take or penalizes them for being late, that suggests the driver is working under company control. That’s one of the red flags courts look for.
Company Policies That Create Employer-Like Control
Some companies create policies that resemble employer rules. If a driver must follow strict schedules, delivery windows, or company safety protocols, the company may be acting like an employer in all but name.
This opens the door for accident victims to argue that the platform should be held responsible for its driver’s actions.
Negligent Hiring, Training, or Supervision
Companies might also be liable if they knowingly hire unsafe drivers or ignore complaints about reckless behavior. If DoorDash or Grubhub failed to properly vet a driver or didn’t follow up on safety warnings, a victim could sue for negligent hiring or supervision.
For instance, if a company knew a driver had a suspended license and allowed them to continue working, it might share responsibility for any crash that followed.
What Insurance Covers Delivery Driver Accidents?
When a DoorDash or Grubhub driver causes a crash, figuring out which insurance policy applies isn't always straightforward. It depends on what the driver was doing, whether they were logged into the app, and what type of coverage they or the company had at the time.
Understanding how these policies work together helps accident victims identify who should pay for their damages.
Driver’s Personal Auto Insurance
Most food delivery drivers use their personal vehicles. They usually carry personal auto insurance, but these policies aren’t meant to cover work-related driving. In fact, most personal policies exclude commercial activities like rideshare or delivery work. That means if a driver gets into an accident while delivering food, their personal policy might not pay for the damages.
Common Exclusions
Insurance companies often write specific exclusions into policies that rule out coverage during:
- Active food delivery
- Rideshare driving (like Uber or Lyft)
- Any use of the car for profit
If a driver failed to tell their insurer they were using the car for delivery work, the company might deny the claim completely.
When Personal Coverage May Still Apply
If the driver was off-duty, not logged into the app, or between delivery shifts, their personal policy could still apply. For example, if they had just finished a delivery and were off the clock, their personal coverage might be triggered.
Company-Provided Coverage
Many delivery platforms provide some form of insurance, but it usually depends on what the driver was doing in the app at the time of the crash.
Contingent Liability Insurance
When drivers are logged in but not actively delivering, companies like DoorDash or Grubhub may offer contingent liability coverage. This means:
- The driver’s personal policy gets billed first
- The platform’s insurance fills in only if the personal policy denies or doesn't fully cover the damages
This coverage typically includes:
- Bodily injury to others (limited)
- Property damage (limited)
Coverage Tiers Based on Driver Status
Most platforms divide coverage into three tiers:
- Driver Logged Out: No company coverage applies. Only personal insurance is responsible.
- Driver Logged In, Waiting for a Job: Contingent liability may apply. Coverage is limited, often around $50,000 per person for bodily injury.
- Driver En Route or Delivering: Full commercial coverage kicks in. This can include:
- Up to $1 million in liability coverage
- Some platforms also offer limited collision coverage (if the driver has it personally)
DoorDash, for example, offers $1 million in coverage for bodily injury and property damage only when the driver is actively delivering an order.
Coordination Between Policies
Accidents often trigger overlapping coverage, with multiple insurers pointing fingers at each other. This can delay payouts, reduce settlement offers, or leave victims confused. Sorting out these insurance layers may require legal help to make sure the right insurer pays the full amount owed.
Third-Party Liability in Delivery Accidents
Not every delivery crash is the driver’s fault. In some cases, others may have contributed or even caused the accident.
- Restaurant Responsibility: If a restaurant hires or contracts with unsafe drivers, they might share the blame. Failing to vet drivers properly could make them liable.
- Property Owners: Poor lighting, broken sidewalks, or unmarked hazards at pickup or drop-off locations can lead to accidents. Property owners might bear some of the responsibility.
- Other Drivers: Multi-car crashes happen often, especially in busy delivery zones. Another driver might have been the true cause of the collision.
- Government Entities: Bad roads, broken signals, or poor signage can contribute to accidents. Cities and counties may sometimes be legally responsible for these problems.
How Do You Prove Negligence in a Delivery Driver Case?
To recover damages, you'll need an attorney to prove that the driver was careless and that their carelessness caused the accident. This can involve several types of evidence.
Establishing Driver Fault
- Common Mistakes: Speeding, distracted driving, and running red lights are frequent causes. Some drivers feel rushed to meet deadlines and take risks.
- Scene Evidence: Photos, police reports, and witness statements help build a strong case.
- Tech Records: GPS data, delivery logs, and dashcams can show how fast the driver was going, where they were, and whether they were following company policy.
Proving Company Liability
- Control Evidence: If the company set strict rules or punished drivers for deviating from their system, that helps show company responsibility.
- Policy Problems: Rules that encourage unsafe driving, like penalties for late deliveries, might also be evidence.
- Pattern of Negligence: If the company has a history of ignoring complaints or cutting corners, that can support a broader claim.
Schedule A Free Case Consultation
Unique Challenges in Delivery Driver Accident Cases
Several factors make these cases tougher than your average car accident.
- Insurance Conflicts: Different policies may argue over who should pay. This can delay settlements.
- Multiple Parties: Victims often have to deal with drivers, platforms, restaurants, property owners, and insurers, all with different interests.
- Evidence Time Limits: GPS logs, dashcam footage, and delivery app data may disappear quickly unless preserved.
- Big Company Defense Teams: Delivery platforms often have large legal teams working to minimize payouts.
- Jurisdictional Conflicts: If the driver, company, and accident occurred in different states, it complicates the legal process.
Compensation Available to Accident Victims
People injured in delivery driver crashes may qualify for many types of compensation.
- Medical Costs: Includes emergency care, surgeries, therapy, and future treatments.
- Lost Income: Covers missed workdays and long-term income loss from injuries.
- Pain and Suffering: This includes physical pain, stress, anxiety, and reduced quality of life.
- Property Damage: Covers repairs or replacement for vehicles and other damaged belongings.
- Wrongful Death: Surviving family members may receive compensation for the loss of a loved one, including burial costs and lost income.
How a Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Your Case
Legal representation helps ensure every potential path to recovery gets explored. Attorneys also handle the headaches so you can focus on healing.
- Finding All Liable Parties: Lawyers investigate thoroughly to include everyone responsible in the claim.
- Coordinating Insurance: Juggling multiple policies and insurers can get complicated. Attorneys deal with those conversations.
- Preserving Electronic Evidence: Quick action can prevent data loss from phones, apps, and vehicle systems.
- Handling Insurers: Victims shouldn’t have to talk to multiple companies or deal with pushy adjusters.
- Measuring Damages Accurately: Lawyers know how to calculate future treatment needs and other hidden costs.
- Fighting Big Defendants: Most delivery platforms have strong legal defenses. You need someone just as determined.
- Staying Compliant with Local Laws: Every state has different rules. A local attorney ensures nothing gets missed.
Frequently Asked Questions About DoorDash or Grubhub Liability
What if the delivery driver doesn't have insurance?
Your own uninsured motorist coverage might apply. You can also pursue damages through the delivery company’s backup insurance or other parties involved.
How long do I have to file a lawsuit after a delivery driver accident?
In Pennsylvania, you generally have two years from the date of the accident to file a lawsuit. Other states have different limits, so it’s best to act quickly.
Can I sue if I was injured as a passenger in a delivery vehicle?
Yes. Passengers can bring claims against the driver, the delivery company, or other at-fault parties.
What if the delivery driver was using multiple apps at the time of the accident?
That can complicate things. The company they were actively working for at the time may bear responsibility, but additional insurers might also be involved.
Do I need to report the accident to the delivery company?
Yes. It helps to document the crash through the app or company’s reporting system. Save screenshots and communication logs.
Let Our Experienced Rideshare Accident Attorneys Help
Acting quickly can make a big difference, especially when it comes to preserving digital evidence and securing full compensation.
The Oakes Firm knows how to handle cases involving delivery platforms like DoorDash and Grubhub. We offer free consultations, and you won’t pay any legal fees unless we recover damages on your behalf. Our firm has a strong track record with delivery driver accidents, and we’re committed to helping clients recover the money they deserve.
Whether you were hit as a pedestrian, another driver, or a passenger, our team of personal injury lawyers is ready to help. Reach out today to start your free case review.